10 Secrets the Insurance Adjuster Won’t Tell You About Your Louisiana Car Accident Claim
Keith Magness, Attorney · Last Updated: November 19, 2026
The insurance adjuster who calls after a New Orleans car accident is paid by the company you are making a claim against, and the company’s goal is to close your claim for as little as possible. The adjuster is not a bad person; minimizing claims is the job. What follows are ten things adjusters know and will not volunteer, each one tied to the Louisiana rule behind it, from New Orleans car accident lawyer Keith Magness. Two things changed in 2026 that make the first conversation with an adjuster more dangerous than it used to be: a driver found 51% or more at fault now recovers nothing, and medical damages are measured by what was paid, not what was billed. Both are below.

1. What Your Case is Worth in Louisiana
I was injured in a car accident and needed medical treatment. How much will I get for pain and suffering on top of my bills?
The adjuster has a number for your claim before the first call, and it is built from a formula: the medical bills (since January 1, 2026, the amount actually paid, not the amount billed, under R.S. 9:2800.27), lost wages, and a multiplier for pain and suffering that the adjuster chooses and will not disclose. Louisiana puts no cap on pain and suffering in a car accident case, and the real ceiling is usually the policy limits: the at-fault driver’s liability policy, which is often the state minimum of $15,000 per person, plus any uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy. The adjuster knows those limits on day one; you do not. The settlement value page explains each piece of the calculation and the 2025 and 2026 law changes that moved the numbers. Keith Magness will tell you what the claim is worth, and what the policy limits are, for free.
2. Signing the Insurance Company’s Release Form May Harm Your Case
The insurance company sent me property damage and medical release forms. Should I sign them without a lawyer?
No. Three documents arrive early and each one has a purpose the adjuster will not explain. A property damage release can contain language that also releases your injury claim; sign it and the injury claim is over. A medical authorization is often written to open your entire medical history, not just the crash records, so the adjuster can look for a pre-existing condition to blame; since May 2025 (Code of Evidence art. 306.1) the burden of proving the crash caused the injury is on you, which makes that history more valuable to the insurer than ever. And a recorded statement is taken to pin your words down before you know what hurts. Keith Magness reviews anything the insurer asks you to sign at no charge and tells you whether it is safe.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: Following an accident, you’re probably going to be asked to sign any number of forms by either the other driver’s insurance company or your own. One of the most common is what we call a medical records release, where they can obtain access to any and all of your medical records, both as a result of the accident and preceding it. No matter who it is, your own insurance company or the other driver’s insurance company, we don’t recommend that you sign any forms at all until you have an opportunity to meet with an attorney.
3. Hiring an Experienced Car Accident Injury Attorney May Benefit Your Case
I have used a family attorney for wills, taxes and real estate. Do I need a lawyer who focuses on accident and injury cases?
Yes, and the adjuster can tell the difference within one phone call. A lawyer who handles injury claims every day knows the adjuster’s formula, the policy limits question, the 30-day deadlines in R.S. 22:1892, the 51% rule, and which medical documentation the new evidence rules require. A lawyer who handles one car accident a year does not, and the insurer prices the claim accordingly. Keith Magness handles car, truck, motorcycle, rideshare and bicycle injury cases and nothing else. The 11 questions to ask before hiring a lawyer page tells you how to check anyone, Keith included.
4. The Bill Collectors Can Be Stopped
My medical bills are piling up and my credit is at risk. How do I stop the collection calls?
Injury claims take months, and the hospital will not wait. Three things slow the collectors down. First, your own coverage pays first: health insurance, and medical payments coverage on your auto policy if you bought it, which pays regardless of fault. Second, providers who treat crash victims will often agree in writing to be paid out of the settlement rather than billing you now, an arrangement Keith Magness sets up for clients. Third, state and federal debt collection laws limit how collectors may contact you. The bills still have to be paid at the end, and under the 2026 paid-not-billed rule the amounts matter, so every bill, payment and write-off is tracked from the start and the liens are negotiated down before the settlement is divided.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: The amount of bills that are incurring following an accident is one thing that we closely monitor and talk to our client about, but that’s not something we want our clients to worry about. Put the case in our hands, let us worry about that. We’ll reach out to you and have those open and honest discussions, especially if there’s an issue with how much insurance may be available in connection with the claim.
5. How to Handle Being Injured By a Relative or Friend
A relative or friend caused the accident that injured me. Can I get a settlement without hurting them financially?
Usually yes, and the adjuster would rather you felt too awkward to ask. The claim is against the driver’s liability insurance, which is exactly what the friend bought the policy for. The insurer defends the claim and pays within the policy limits; your friend’s own money is at risk only above those limits, and only if you choose to pursue it. If you were a passenger in your friend’s car, their policy covers you, and your own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage may add to it. Keith Magness handles these claims within the limits, so the friendship and the recovery both survive.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: If you’ve been injured as a result of a friend or a loved one’s fault, there are still remedies available. Quite often when an accident occurs, if a family member or a friend, a cousin, whatnot, was driving the car, the injured people inside that vehicle are really apprehensive and don’t want to sue them. Know that, typically, there’s insurance involved, and there are ways that we can attempt to receive compensation for your injuries where it won’t injure that loved one or that friend personally, and limit the recovery to the insurance that’s available.
6. What to Do If Injured by an Uninsured or Underinsured Driver
The driver who hit me had no insurance. My policy says I have uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. What does that mean?
It means your own insurance company steps into the other driver’s shoes and pays what that driver should have paid, up to your UM limits, for injuries caused by an uninsured driver or a driver whose limits are too low. Louisiana requires UM coverage on every auto policy unless you rejected it on the state form (R.S. 22:1295), and about one Louisiana driver in nine carries no insurance at all (11.7% in 2023, Insurance Research Council). Here is the second secret: your own company adjusts a UM claim the same way the other driver’s company would, to pay as little as possible, and years of premiums do not change that. What does change things: the insurer may not raise your rates or drop you for a claim that was not your fault (R.S. 22:1284), and the UM claim has its own two-year deadline. The uninsured motorist page covers how these claims work.
7. How To Know If You Are Getting a Fair Offer From the Insurance Adjuster
I thought about negotiating with the insurance company on my own. How can I know if the offer is fair?
You cannot, from the outside, because the three numbers that define “fair” are the ones the adjuster will not share: the policy limits, the percentage of fault the insurer has assigned to you, and the value it has placed on your injuries. The first offer is a test of what you will accept, and since January 1, 2026 the fault number carries more weight than ever, because a claimant pushed to 51% recovers nothing. A fair offer is one made with the full medical picture, after you have reached maximum medical improvement, with the fault question settled by evidence rather than by the adjuster’s say-so. The low settlement offer page walks through how a lowball offer is answered. Under R.S. 22:1892 an insurer must make a written offer within 30 days of receiving proof of loss; a written offer is also the trigger for Keith’s more-money-in-your-pocket guarantee below.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: If you’re offered some money or a check right away from an insurance company after your accident, do not under any circumstance agree to take that check, sign it, cash it, or anything, because it could greatly impact your rights moving forward. Instead, you should contact a local personal injury law firm like ours. We’ll be happy to take a look at it and advise you on whether or not this is the best scenario for you. Quite often these insurance companies know that accident victims don’t know their rights. They try and take advantage of that. That’s why they try and give you a check immediately in an effort to settle the claim, most often for less than what it’s actually worth.
8. Whether or Not Your Case Will Go to Trial
If I hire a lawyer, will my case have to go to trial?
Probably not. Most Louisiana car accident claims settle without a lawsuit, and most lawsuits settle before trial, because a trial costs both sides time and money and a jury verdict is a risk for both. What the adjuster will not say is that the settlement offer depends on whether a trial is a real possibility. A claimant with no lawyer is no threat to try the case, and the offer reflects that. A lawyer who files suit in the 24th Judicial District Court in Gretna or Orleans Civil District Court when the insurer will not pay a fair number, and is prepared to try it, changes the insurer’s math. Keith Magness settles cases when the number is right and tries them when it is not.
9. The Insurance Adjuster Cannot Limit the Medical Treatment You Receive
I need to see a specialist for my injuries. Can the insurance company limit which doctors I see?
No. The at-fault driver’s insurer does not direct your care; you choose your doctors. What the insurer owes is the cost of medical treatment that was reasonable and necessary because of the crash, within the policy limits, and the adjuster will dispute treatment it considers excessive or unrelated. That makes two things essential: get treated promptly after the crash, because a gap in treatment is read as proof you were not hurt, and follow the treatment plan, because missed appointments are read the same way. Keep every record and receipt. If you have no health insurance, Keith Magness can help you find care that will treat you now and wait for the settlement.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: After a car accident, again, the most important thing you can do is to seek medical help right away, 1.) To document the nature of your injury, and 2.) To help you along on your path. Sometimes insurance companies will try and point you in the direction of a preferred care provider that they may have in their network, if you will. You absolutely have the right to chose what doctor you want to go see. If that doctor is not one of the preferred doctors for the insurance company, you still have the right to go to your own doctor. If the doctor happens to be on the insurance company’s preferred list, well, that may make things easier at the end of the day, but it is your choice as the injured person as to which doctor you see to provide the care for you.
10. Why the Adjuster Says You Do Not Need a Lawyer
Why does the insurance adjuster say they can settle my case easily without a lawyer?
Because it is cheaper for the insurer. An unrepresented claimant does not know the policy limits, cannot evaluate the fault percentage, does not know the 30-day rules, and will sign the first release that comes with a check. It is not illegal for the adjuster to value your claim low; it is the job. The Insurance Research Council’s 1999 study found that injured people who hired a lawyer received, on average, about three and a half times the gross settlement of those who did not, before fees; the study is old and the insurance industry disputes how to read it, but the reason behind it has not changed. The insurance company does not want you to know what your claim is worth, and a lawyer who handles these claims every day does.
Call the Law Office of Keith L. Magness at (504) 264-5587 for a free consultation before you give a recorded statement or sign anything. The fee is 30% of the recovery if the claim settles before suit and 37% if suit is necessary; most New Orleans firms charge 40%. Read how the fee works.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: Even though you can negotiate directly with the insurance company and try to come to some settlement, you should always involve an attorney. First and foremost, most people aren’t familiar with the insurance claims process, and it can be overwhelming. An attorney, based on their experience, especially at our office, is well versed in handling these things. Secondly, and most importantly, the insurance companies’ own studies show that individuals who retain the services of a professional personal injury law firm like ours, on average, receive three and a half times more compensation than people who try to go it alone. What that means is, if you try and represent yourself, on average you’re going to receive less money as compensation than if you hired an attorney to represent you.
Keith Magness’s Guarantee to You
If the insurance company has already made you a written offer, Keith’s guarantee is that you will net more money in your pocket after the fee than that offer would have paid you. If not, the fee is reduced or waived.
Questions About Insurance Adjusters in Louisiana
Should I give the insurance adjuster a recorded statement?
Not to the other driver’s insurer, and not before you have talked to a lawyer. You have no legal duty to give the at-fault insurer a recorded statement. Your own policy may require you to cooperate with your own company, which a lawyer can handle with you.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: While there may be a requirement to provide a statement to your own insurance company after an accident, depending on what your insurance policy provides, there’s absolutely no requirement that you have to give a statement to the other driver’s insurance company. Regardless, if you’re going to give a statement to your insurance company, or the other driver’s insurance company, you should only do so with the advice of an attorney and having that attorney present whenever you do it.
Does the insurance adjuster work for me?
No. The adjuster works for the insurance company that will pay the claim, including when it is your own company on a UM claim. Courteous and helpful are part of the job; so is paying as little as possible.
How long does the adjuster have to respond to my claim in Louisiana?
Under R.S. 22:1892 the insurer must begin adjusting a property damage claim within 14 days of notice, make a written offer within 30 days of receiving satisfactory proof of loss, and pay within 30 days of a written settlement. Missing those deadlines without good cause exposes the insurer to a penalty of 50% of the amount due or $1,000, whichever is greater, plus attorney fees.
Can the adjuster use my social media against me?
Yes. Adjusters and defense lawyers look at public posts for photos and comments that contradict the injury claim. Assume anything you post will be read by the insurer, and post nothing about the crash or your activities until the claim is over.
What is the 51% rule and why does the adjuster care?
Since January 1, 2026, a Louisiana driver who is 51% or more at fault recovers nothing, and a driver under 51% loses that percentage of the claim. Every question about what you did, how fast you were going, or whether you were distracted is aimed at that number.
Should I accept the first settlement offer?
Rarely. The first offer is made before the insurer knows whether you will push back, and often before your treatment is finished. Once you sign the release, the claim cannot be reopened, even if an injury turns out to be worse than it looked.
