Negotiating a Low Car Accident Settlement Offer in New Orleans
Keith Magness, Attorney · Last Updated: November 19, 2026
A low first offer after a car accident is the adjuster’s opening position, not the insurance company’s valuation of your claim. The number is designed to find out whether you will take it. Here is what to do, in order: do not accept it and do not sign anything; ask for the basis of the offer in writing; finish your treatment, or at least get a prognosis, before you talk numbers; counter in writing with your documents attached and a deadline; and if the injury is more than a few weeks of soreness, talk to a lawyer before you send the counter.
Keith Magness is a New Orleans car accident lawyer based in Gretna who handles motor vehicle injury cases only. Before opening the Law Office of Keith L. Magness in 2011, Keith worked for several major auto insurers, including Allstate, State Farm, Liberty Mutual, Metropolitan and Safeco, which is where he learned how the first offer gets built. The consultation is free, and the firm’s written guarantee is specific to this situation: if Keith Magness does not put more money in your pocket than the insurance company already offered, the attorney fee is reduced or waived.
On this page
- Why is the insurance company’s offer so low?
- How do you know if a settlement offer is fair?
- Do you have to accept the insurance company’s offer?
- Can you negotiate a car accident settlement without a lawyer?
- How do you counter a low settlement offer?
- What should you never say or sign while negotiating?
- Can you get more than the policy limits in Louisiana?
- What Louisiana law says about settlement offers and payment
- How long does negotiation take, and when do you stop?
- When should you call Keith Magness about a low offer?
- Low settlement offer questions
If the low offer is for your car rather than your injuries, the vehicle damage claim guide covers total loss value, the valuation rules, rental and diminished value.
Why Is the Insurance Company’s Offer So Low?
Insurance companies make low first offers because low first offers get accepted. An adjuster handles hundreds of claims, is measured on what each one costs, and knows that a person with medical bills arriving and a car in the shop will often take a quick number. The offer is not an insult and it is not a mistake. It is the first move. Six things decide how low that move is.
The offer is an opening position
Adjusters are trained negotiators and they expect a counter. A first offer that is accepted is a file closed under budget; one that is rejected costs the company nothing. The first number is almost never the real number.
The adjuster is betting you are not represented
Unrepresented claimants settle for less. A person without a lawyer is unlikely to know what the claim is worth, unlikely to file suit, and likely to run out of patience before the company does. The offer is priced accordingly, and it changes the day a lawyer’s letter arrives.
The file is thin
An adjuster can only value what is in the file. Missing records, a gap in treatment, no proof of lost income, or no documentation of pain and limitation each give the adjuster a reason to discount. Much of what looks like bad faith is simply a claim that was never documented.
Fault is in dispute
Since January 1, 2026, Louisiana uses modified comparative fault with a 51% bar. A claimant found 51% or more at fault recovers nothing; below that, the recovery is reduced by the claimant’s share. Any ambiguity in the police report or a witness statement is now worth money to the insurer, and a low offer often carries an unstated fault discount.
The policy limit is the ceiling
Louisiana’s required minimum auto liability coverage is $15,000 per person and $30,000 per accident for bodily injury (R.S. 32:900), and a large share of New Orleans drivers carry exactly that. When the at-fault driver has a minimum policy, the insurer will not offer more than the limit no matter how serious the injury. The section on policy limits covers where the rest of the money can come from.
Three law changes made first offers lower in 2025 and 2026
Offers in Louisiana dropped for reasons that have nothing to do with your injury. First, for suits filed on or after January 1, 2026, past medical expenses paid by health insurance or Medicare are recoverable only in the amount actually paid plus your cost sharing, not the amount billed (Act 466 of 2025, R.S. 9:2800.27), so adjusters now value a $20,000 hospital bill at what the health plan paid for it. Second, since May 28, 2025, the lack of a prior injury no longer creates a presumption that the crash caused your condition (Code of Evidence art. 306.1); you have to prove causation with medical evidence, and adjusters discount claims that have not. Third, the 51% bar above. A low offer usually reflects the paperwork, not the injury. The settlement value guide walks through all three changes with examples.
One more rule applies if you were driving without insurance: Louisiana’s No Pay, No Play law bars the first $100,000 of injury damages and $100,000 of property damage, with exceptions, and the adjuster will apply it.
How Do You Know If a Settlement Offer Is Fair?
A settlement offer is fair when it covers every category of loss the law allows, at the amounts your records support, within the insurance available. The adjuster builds the number from two parts: special damages, which are the medical expenses (now measured by what was paid), lost income, mileage to appointments, and property loss; and general damages, which are pain, suffering, loss of enjoyment of life and the effect of the injury on your daily routine. Louisiana puts no cap on either category in a car accident case.
Measure the offer against this list, not against the first number that sounds like a lot of money:
- Every medical bill to date, at the paid amount, including the emergency visit, imaging, therapy and prescriptions
- Treatment your doctor says is still ahead, at a documented estimate
- Lost wages, lost commissions or overtime, and sick days used, with employer confirmation
- Reduced earning capacity if the injury limits the work you can do
- Pain, suffering and the loss of activities you can no longer do, supported by your records and your journal
- Property damage, rental, diminished value and towing, if they are in the same claim
Three signs an offer is low: it arrives before your treatment is finished, it equals or barely exceeds the medical bills with nothing for pain and suffering, or the adjuster cannot tell you in writing how it was calculated. Keith Magness does not quote typical settlement amounts on this site, because two claims with the same injury can be worth very different amounts depending on fault, documentation and coverage. What he can do in a free consultation is tell you whether the number on the table is in the range your file supports.
Do You Have to Accept the Insurance Company’s Offer?
No. A settlement offer from the other driver’s insurer is a proposal, and you can reject it, counter it, or ignore it. The only deadline that matters in Louisiana is the filing deadline: two years from the date of the crash for accidents on or after July 1, 2024 (Act 423 of 2024, La. Civil Code art. 3493.1), one year for earlier crashes. As long as a lawsuit is filed before that date, no offer “expires” in a way that costs you the claim. An adjuster who says the offer is good until Friday is creating pressure, not a legal deadline.
Two things are final. A signed release ends the claim; once the check clears, there is no reopening it when the pain comes back in March. And an accepted offer is accepted even if a better one would have come. Rejecting an offer does not make it disappear; in practice the insurer leaves it open, and the next move is the counter below.
Can You Negotiate a Car Accident Settlement Without a Lawyer?
You can negotiate without a lawyer, and for some claims you should. If the only dispute is the car, the vehicle damage guide on this site walks through doing that yourself, because a lawyer’s fee on a property damage claim rarely makes sense. If you were not hurt, or you saw a doctor once, missed no work, and the soreness was gone in a week, a short written counter with your bills attached is a reasonable way to handle it.
The math changes once there is an injury that needed treatment. An adjuster values an unrepresented claim lower than a represented one, and the gap is usually larger than the fee; the 10 Secrets page covers the industry’s own 1999 study on that gap and what the adjuster will not tell you about it. Keith Magness charges 30% of the recovery when a case settles before suit, which is how most car accident claims end, and 37% if suit has to be filed; most New Orleans injury firms charge 33% to 40% from the first day. The fees page shows a settlement statement line by line.
Three situations where negotiating alone costs money: fault is disputed, because the 51% rule turns every fault argument into a percentage of your recovery; the injury involves a disc, a fracture, a concussion or surgery, because those claims are valued on prognosis, not on bills to date; and the at-fault driver has a minimum policy, because finding the other coverage is the whole case.
How Do You Counter a Low Settlement Offer?
Counter a low settlement offer in writing, with documents, with a number, and with a deadline. Phone negotiations leave no record and favor the person who does this all day. The steps:
- Decline the offer in writing. One paragraph. State that the offer does not reflect the documented damages and that you will send a demand. Do not argue, do not explain your finances, and do not say what you would accept.
- Finish building the file. Police report, every medical record and bill, the paid amounts from your health insurer’s explanation of benefits, a letter from your employer confirming time missed and pay rate, photos of the vehicles and the injuries, and your daily journal of pain and limitation. If treatment is ongoing, get your doctor’s written prognosis and the estimated cost of what is ahead.
- Write the demand. A demand letter sets out the facts of the crash, why the other driver was at fault, each injury and its treatment, each category of damages with the supporting documents attached, and the amount demanded. It is organized the way the adjuster’s file is organized, so the adjuster can justify a higher reserve to a supervisor.
- Set the number with room to move. The demand is the top of the range your documents support, not the number you expect to receive. Every counter after that moves in smaller steps, and the insurer’s moves tell you where the real authority is.
- Put a deadline on it. Thirty days is customary. A time-limited demand within the policy limits also matters for a different reason, covered under policy limits below.
- Keep a log. Date, adjuster’s name, what was said, what was promised. Confirm every phone call with a short email the same day.
A short counteroffer letter that does the job:
Re: Claim No. [number], date of loss [date]
I have received your offer of [amount] dated [date]. The offer does not reflect the documented losses from this collision. Enclosed are the police report, my medical records and bills (with the amounts paid), my employer’s confirmation of [number] days of missed work at [rate], and photographs of the vehicles and my injuries. My medical expenses to date total [amount], my lost income totals [amount], and my physician’s prognosis, enclosed, calls for [treatment] at an estimated cost of [amount]. Taking into account those losses and the pain and limitation documented in the enclosed records, I demand [amount] in full settlement. Please respond in writing within 30 days. I am not providing a recorded statement, and I have not authorized the release of any medical records beyond those enclosed.
[Name, address, phone]
Keith Magness sends a version of this letter with one difference: it arrives on a law firm’s letterhead with a filing deadline the adjuster knows the firm will keep.
What Should You Never Say or Sign While Negotiating?
The adjuster’s file is built partly from what you give them. Four things to withhold:
- A recorded statement. You are not required to give the other driver’s insurer a recorded statement, and nothing in it helps you. Decline politely and put the facts in writing instead.
- An open medical authorization. The standard form lets the insurer pull your entire medical history, which it then searches for a prior complaint to pin the injury on. Under art. 306.1 that search matters more than it used to. Provide the records for this injury yourself.
- “I’m fine” or “I’m okay.” Adjusters write it down. Say that you are being treated and will provide the records.
- A release, or a check marked “full and final.” Cashing it can end the claim. A partial payment is only partial if the paperwork says so and no release was signed.
The 18 Mistakes page covers the rest, including the apology at the scene and the gap in treatment, both of which show up as discounts in the first offer.
Can You Get More Than the Policy Limits in Louisiana?
Not from the at-fault driver’s insurer. An auto liability policy pays up to its limit and no more, and in Louisiana that limit is often the $15,000 per person minimum under R.S. 32:900. When the injury is worth more than the policy, the money comes from somewhere else, and finding it is most of the work in a serious case:
- Your own uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. If your damages exceed the other driver’s limit, your UM/UIM coverage pays the difference up to its own limit. Louisiana policies carry it unless it was rejected in writing on the state form (R.S. 22:1295). The UM coverage page explains how the claim works and why a rejection form that was not filled out properly may not count.
- Other policies that cover the at-fault driver. An umbrella policy, an employer’s policy if the driver was working, the policy on a borrowed vehicle, or a commercial policy on a rideshare or delivery vehicle.
- More than one defendant. A second driver, a vehicle owner, an employer, or a public body responsible for the road each bring their own coverage.
There is one way the policy limit stops being the ceiling. An insurer owes its own insured a duty to settle a claim within the policy limits when a reasonable opportunity to do so exists. A time-limited demand for the policy limits, supported by documentation showing the claim is worth more, puts the insurer to that choice. If it unreasonably refuses and a judgment later exceeds the limits, the insurer can be exposed for the excess. That is leverage a lawyer uses on your behalf; it is not money a claimant can collect by asking for it.
What Louisiana Law Says About Settlement Offers and Payment
Louisiana has no statute that forces an insurer to make a fair bodily injury offer to the other driver, but it does set clocks and penalties that shape how a claim is handled (R.S. 22:1892):
- An insurer must make a written offer to settle any property damage claim, including a third-party claim, within 30 days after it receives satisfactory proof of loss.
- An insurer must pay a third-party property damage or medical expense claim within 30 days of a written settlement agreement, and must pay its own insured within 30 days of satisfactory proof of loss.
- An arbitrary and capricious failure to pay on time carries a penalty of 50% of the amount due or $1,000, whichever is greater, plus attorney fees and costs.
R.S. 22:1973 adds a duty of good faith and fair dealing that an insurer owes its own insured, with penalties for misrepresenting the policy or failing to pay a settlement on time. Those statutes are why the demand and every follow-up go in writing: the clock starts on a written agreement and a documented proof of loss, not on a phone call.
How Long Does Negotiation Take, and When Do You Stop?
Negotiation of a car accident claim in New Orleans usually takes a few weeks once the demand is sent, but the demand should not go out until treatment is finished or the doctor has given a prognosis, which is where most of the time goes. The sequence is treatment to maximum medical improvement or a prognosis, the demand package, the insurer’s response (typically two to six weeks), one to three rounds of counters, and then either a settlement or a decision to file suit in the 24th Judicial District Court in Gretna or Orleans Civil District Court, depending on where the crash happened and who the defendant is.
Settle when the offer covers the documented losses, the prognosis is clear, and the remaining gap is smaller than the cost and delay of a lawsuit. File when the insurer’s moves have gotten small, fault or causation is being disputed with nothing new, the two-year deadline is approaching, or the claim is worth more than the policy limit and the insurer will not pay the limit. Filing does not mean a trial; most filed cases still settle, often at mediation, because the insurer’s cost goes up the day suit is filed.
Settling early to make the bills stop is the most common expensive decision in these cases. The car accident recovery page covers who pays the medical bills while a claim is open, which is the pressure the early offer counts on.
When Should You Call Keith Magness About a Low Offer?
Call before you send the counter if any of these is true: your treatment lasted more than a few weeks or is still going; you missed work; the other driver or the adjuster is disputing fault; the offer is below your medical bills, or close to them; the at-fault driver has a minimum policy; or the adjuster is pressing you to sign quickly. Each one changes the value of the claim in ways that do not show up in a bill total.
The firm’s second written guarantee exists for this call. If Keith Magness does not put more cash in your pocket than what the insurance company has offered, the attorney fee is reduced or waived. Bring the offer letter, and Keith will tell you in the first conversation whether the firm can beat it after its fee. The other two guarantees, including the 30-day walk-away, are on the guarantees page.
What changes when the firm takes over: the demand goes out on letterhead with a deadline, the adjuster deals with a lawyer who spent years on the insurer’s side of these files, the medical bills and liens get negotiated down as part of the settlement, and the policy-limits question gets answered before the first counter. The consultation is free, and there is no fee unless Keith recovers money for you.
Low Settlement Offer Questions
Can I negotiate a car accident settlement without a lawyer?
Yes, and for a property damage claim or a minor injury with no missed work it is often the right call. Once there is an injury that needed ongoing treatment, disputed fault, or a minimum policy, an adjuster values the unrepresented claim lower by more than a lawyer’s fee. Keith Magness will tell you in a free consultation which kind of claim you have.
How long do I have to respond to a settlement offer?
There is no legal deadline to respond to an offer from the other driver’s insurer. The deadline that matters is the two-year filing deadline for crashes on or after July 1, 2024 (one year for earlier crashes). An adjuster’s “offer expires Friday” is a negotiating tactic, not a rule.
Should I accept the first settlement offer?
Almost never, and never before treatment is finished or a doctor has given a prognosis. The first offer is an opening position priced for an unrepresented claimant. Decline it in writing and counter with documents.
What if I was partly at fault for the crash?
Under Louisiana’s modified comparative fault rule, in effect since January 1, 2026, a claimant who is 51% or more at fault recovers nothing, and a claimant below that line recovers damages reduced by their percentage of fault. A 20% share of fault means a 20% reduction. Adjusters know this, which is why the first offer often carries a fault discount that was never explained.
What should I include in a counteroffer?
A demand letter with the facts of the crash, the basis for the other driver’s fault, each injury and its treatment, medical bills at the paid amounts, proof of lost income, the doctor’s prognosis and the cost of future treatment, photographs, a demand amount, and a 30-day deadline. Attach the documents; do not describe them.
Can I still negotiate after accepting a partial payment?
Only if no release was signed and the payment was documented as partial. A check cashed with “full and final settlement” on it, or a signed release, usually ends the claim. Read anything the insurer sends with a check before cashing it.
Will hiring a lawyer delay my settlement?
Usually the opposite. A represented claim gets a real offer sooner because the adjuster knows the file will be documented and the deadline will be kept. The time in any injury claim is the treatment, not the negotiation, and a lawyer cannot shorten the healing.
What happens if we cannot agree on a settlement?
The claim is filed as a lawsuit before the two-year deadline, in the 24th Judicial District Court or Orleans Civil District Court. Most filed cases still settle, many at mediation, because the insurer’s cost rises once suit is filed. Keith Magness files when the offer stays below what the file supports, and the fee rises once, to 37%, and never again, even at trial.
Get the Offer Reviewed Before You Answer It
Call (504) 264-5587 or send the offer letter for a free review. Keith Magness will tell you whether the number is in the range your file supports and what the next letter should say. No fee unless the firm recovers money for you, and if the result is not more than the insurer’s offer after the fee, the fee is reduced or waived. More answers on the Louisiana Car Accident FAQ.
