Why Hire a New Orleans Car Accident Lawyer?
Keith Magness, Attorney · Last Updated: November 19, 2026
Hire a car accident lawyer when you were injured, when fault is disputed, or when the insurance company has already made an offer, and do it before you give a recorded statement or sign anything. If the crash damaged only your car and no one was hurt, you probably do not need one; the vehicle damage claim guide walks you through that yourself. For an injury claim, the reasons to hire a lawyer are not slogans. They are four changes in Louisiana law since 2024 that moved the advantage further toward the insurance company, plus the fee math, plus the three written guarantees Keith Magness makes to every client.
What Changes When You Hire a Car Accident Lawyer in Louisiana
An injured person who handles the claim alone is negotiating with a trained adjuster who settles claims for a living, who knows the policy limits and you do not, and who knows whether a lawsuit is a real possibility. Five things change when a lawyer takes the file:
- The 51% rule is handled from day one. Since January 1, 2026, a driver who is 51% or more at fault recovers nothing, and a driver under 51% loses that percentage of the claim (Act 15 of 2025). Every question the adjuster asks about what you did is aimed at that number. A lawyer answers for you, gathers the police report, photos and witnesses, and fixes the fault percentage before the insurer does.
- The medical bills are proved the way the new law requires. For suits filed on or after January 1, 2026, past medical expenses are limited to what was actually paid, not what was billed (R.S. 9:2800.27, Act 466 of 2025), and since May 2025 an injured person must prove, with medical evidence, that the crash caused the injury (Code of Evidence art. 306.1, Act 18 of 2025). Building that record means the right doctors, the right documentation, and knowing which bills count.
- Every policy is found. The at-fault driver’s policy is often Louisiana’s $15,000 minimum. A lawyer identifies the other coverage: your own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, an employer’s commercial policy, an umbrella, a rideshare company’s policy, and makes the claims in the right order so none is waived.
- The insurer’s deadlines are enforced. R.S. 22:1892 gives an insurer 30 days to make a written offer after proof of loss and 30 days to pay after a written settlement, with a penalty of 50% of the amount due plus attorney fees when the delay is arbitrary, and R.S. 22:1973 adds a general duty of good faith with its own penalties. Adjusters know which claimants will use those statutes.
- The release is read before it is signed. Property damage releases that also release the injury claim, recorded statements, and medical authorizations that open your whole history are routine insurer tools. The ten secrets the adjuster will not share page lists the rest.
Keith Magness on when to call:
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: You should immediately contact an attorney following a car accident. After a car accident, so many things are going to happen. You’re going to have doctor’s appointments, medical bills, insurance adjusters calling you. Most people just don’t understand the nature of an insurance claim following an accident. It’s best to call an attorney right away, like our firm, who can take that worry off of you so you can concentrate on what’s most important which is your healing after the accident.
Does Hiring a Lawyer Cost More Than It Recovers?
Usually the opposite, and the fee is the number to check before you sign with anyone. Most New Orleans injury firms charge 33% to 40% from the first day and raise the rate once suit is filed. The Law Office of Keith L. Magness charges 30% if the claim settles before a lawsuit is filed, which is how most car accident claims end, and 37% if suit is necessary, and the fee never rises again, even at trial. On a $100,000 settlement reached before suit, that is a $10,000 difference against a 40% firm. The fees page shows a settlement statement line by line. There is no retainer, no hourly bill, and no fee at all if there is no recovery.
Why Hire Keith Magness: Three Written Guarantees
Keith Magness is a New Orleans personal injury attorney whose practice is limited to car, truck, motorcycle, rideshare and bicycle accident injury cases. After going through the claims process as a law student when his mother was killed in a car accident, Keith built the firm to treat clients differently from the way the insurance company, and much of the legal industry, treated his family. Three written guarantees hold the firm to that.
Transcript of the video. Keith Magness: No attorney has a crystal ball and it would be unethical for them to try and guarantee any particular financial result that would come out of your accident. Our firm can guarantee a few things. First, here at the Law Office of Keith Magness, we have a thirty-day, one-hundred percent satisfaction guarantee. What that means is if within the first thirty days of our representing you, if we’re not living up to the promises that we’ve made as far as the quality of representation and service that we’re going to provide, or you just simply change your mind for any reason whatsoever, you can come into our office, and ask for your file back. We will give it to you, and we will waive our fee. We won’t file an attorney lien. Secondly, at our office, if you’ve already received a cash offer to settle your case from the insurance company, and we take your case, if at the end of the day, after factoring in attorney’s fees as well, we’re not able to put more money in your pocket than that insurance company has already offered you, we’ll waive our fee. Third, it’s often a concern of clients that as the medical bills add up in a case, Will they see anything at the end of the day after the doctors and lawyers are paid? What we guarantee to our clients is this: No matter how high the medical bills get, and what insurance is available to recover from, if at the end of the day, we’re not able to put money in your pocket, we’ll waive our fee as well.
1) 100% Satisfaction Guarantee: Walk Away Within 30 Days and the Fee Is Waived
If, within the first 30 days after hiring Keith Magness to represent you in a motor vehicle accident claim, you are not completely satisfied with how the claim is being handled, you can end the engagement and the firm waives its attorney fee for the work done in those 30 days. At most firms a departing client owes quantum meruit, the value of the work performed; here, nothing. The 100% Satisfaction Guarantee page has the full terms.
2) More Money in Your Pocket Than the Insurance Company Offered, or the Fee Is Reduced or Waived
Many people call after the insurance company has already made an offer. If you have a written offer from the insurer and you hire Keith Magness, the guarantee is that you will net more money after the fee than that offer would have put in your pocket. If not, the fee is reduced or waived so that you do.
3) Money in Your Pocket Regardless of the Medical Bills, or the Fee Is Waived
Medical bills add up quickly after a crash, and many clients worry that the bills and the fee will consume the settlement and leave them nothing. The guarantee: whatever insurance turns out to be available, if the firm cannot put money in your pocket at the end of the claim, the fee is waived.
Questions About Hiring a Car Accident Lawyer in New Orleans
Do I need a lawyer for a minor car accident?
Not if the only damage is to the car and no one was hurt; the property damage claim is one you can settle yourself. If anyone was injured, even what seems minor, talk to a lawyer before you give a recorded statement or sign a release. Soft-tissue injuries often worsen over days, and a release signed early ends the claim.
When should I hire a car accident lawyer?
Before the first substantive conversation with the other driver’s insurer, and in any case before you sign anything. The evidence that decides the 51% question (photos, witnesses, the crash report, vehicle data) is easiest to get in the first days. Louisiana’s deadline to file suit is two years from a crash on or after July 1, 2024, but the claim is usually won or lost long before that.
What does a car accident lawyer actually do?
Takes over all contact with the insurers, investigates fault, identifies every available policy, coordinates medical documentation to meet Louisiana’s proof requirements, calculates the claim’s value, negotiates, and files suit in the 24th Judicial District Court or Orleans Civil District Court if the insurer will not pay a fair number.
How much does a car accident lawyer cost in New Orleans?
Nothing up front. Keith Magness charges a contingency fee of 30% of the recovery if the case settles before suit and 37% if suit is filed; most New Orleans firms charge 33% to 40% and raise it once suit is filed. If there is no recovery, there is no fee.
Can I switch car accident lawyers if I am unhappy?
Yes. Louisiana clients can change lawyers at any time, but the first lawyer is usually owed the value of the work already done, which comes out of the eventual settlement. Keith Magness waives that for the first 30 days under the 100% Satisfaction Guarantee, so a client who leaves in that window owes nothing.
Will the insurance company offer more if I have a lawyer?
Adjusters value claims partly on the risk of a lawsuit and on how well the injury is documented. An unrepresented claimant presents little of either. A represented claimant with documented injuries and a lawyer who files suit when needed is valued differently. No lawyer can guarantee a particular result, which is why Keith’s guarantees are about the fee, not the outcome.
What is the “more money in your pocket” guarantee?
If the insurance company made you a written offer before you hired Keith Magness, the firm guarantees you will net more after the fee than that offer would have paid you, or the fee is reduced or waived to make that true.
Talk to Keith Magness Before You Talk to the Adjuster
Call (504) 264-5587 or request a free consultation. The office is at 519 Huey P. Long Avenue, Suite 216, in Gretna, and the first conversation can happen by phone the same day.

